M1 Finance is a fee-free platform that combines investing, cash management, and borrowing under one roof. A drawback, however, is that it doesn’t offer human advisor support or provide tax-loss harvesting. Instead, M1 Finance has a tax minimization feature to reduce investors’ owed taxes.
Business Insider’s personal finance team compared M1 Finance Investing to the best stock trading apps and found it an industry leader in portfolio diversification and customization.
Pros and Cons
M1 Finance Pros
- Offers multiple investment options, including crypto and trusts
- DIY and automatic investing strategies
- Tax minimization features
- Fractional share investing
- Auto-reinvest dividends
M1 Finance Cons
- Doesn’t offer mutual funds, futures, or options trading
- Doesn’t offer advanced features like tax-loss harvesting
Open an Account
M1 Finance
Account Minimum
$100 ($500 for IRAs)
Fees
0% (cryptocurrencies are commission-free, but Apex Crypto takes 1% fee on transactions); $10/month M1 Plus
- Low minimum deposit
- Access to more than 80 professional portfolios
- Fractional shares and individual stock or ETF orders available; cryptocurrency trading
- Automated investing available at no additional fee for standard accounts
- Investment options are limited to stocks, ETFs, and cryptocurrencies; no tax-loss harvesting
- Only M1 Plus members can trade crypto 24/7
- Trading window limits your control over investment transactions
- No human advisor support
Insider’s Take
M1 Finance is one of the best investment apps and could be a good choice if you’re interested in trading stocks, ETFs, fractional shares, and cryptocurrencies. It offers both DIY trading and automated account features that make it suitable for both active and passive investors.
Product Details
- Promotion: New M1 Finance users who open a brokerage account can earn up to $500 if they invest at least $75 in their account within 14 days of opening (offer ends December 31, 2024)
Compare M1 Finance
SoFi Active Invest®
Account Minimum
$0 ($1 to start investing); $5 fractional shares; $2,000 for margin trading
Fees
0% for active trading and automated investing
Get up to $1,000 in stock when you fund a new account.
- No account minimum
- No account or trading fees, and low fees to own funds
- Access to Certified Financial Planners at no additional charge
- IPOs available
- SoFi 1% IRA match
- No tax-loss harvesting, an advanced investing technique where you sell a stock or mutual fund at a loss for a tax benefit
- No option for stop-loss orders when actively investing. SoFi’s active investing account only uses market orders
- Currently only available to US residents
Product Details
- Promotion: Get up to $1,000 in stock when you fund a new account.
- App store rating: 4.8 iOS/3.8 Android
- Consider it if: You want an easy-to-use platform paired with rock-bottom pricing.
Robinhood Investing
Account Minimum
$0 ($1 for fractional shares; $2,000 for margin trading)
Fees
0% ($5/month for Robinhood Gold)
- Free stock, option, ETF, and cryptocurrency trades; 0.01% APY on uninvested cash for non-Gold users and 4.00% for Gold members
- IPO investing available
- Cash management accounts available
- Website is easy to navigate; advanced charts for all users
- Lack of investing research and trading tools; can only take advantage of professional research if you’re a Robinhood Gold member
- No joint accounts, education savings accounts, or mutual funds
Product Details
- App store rating: 4.2 iOS/4.0 Android
- Consider it if: You want to trade crypto and invest in a wide range of stocks and ETFs.
Wealthfront Investing
Account Minimum
$1 ($500 for automated investing)
Fees
$0 for stock trades. 0.25% for automated investing (0.06% to 0.13% for fund fees)
- Low annual fee for investment accounts; crypto trust investments available
- Tax-loss harvesting, portfolio lines of credit, 529 college savings plans available
- Cash account
- Mobile app and investing and retirement tools
- You need at least $100,000 to utilize additional investment strategies
- No human advisor access
Product Details
- Consider it if: You’re balancing several goals and want to streamline your finances.
- Promotion: Fund your first taxable investment account with at least $500 in the first 30 days of account opening and earn a $50 bonus.
M1 Finance Overview
M1 Finance is an intuitive wealth-building platform offering automated investing with personalized portfolios. Designed for long-term investing, M1 Finance offers individual brokerage accounts, IRAs, a crypto-trading account, and trust accounts for passive and active traders. Margin trading and commission-free trades are also available.
M1 Finance doesn’t provide tax-loss harvesting. Instead, it has a tax minimization feature to minimize investors’ owed amount in taxes. It reduces your taxes by first selling investment securities with the lowest tax burden. This includes short-term capital loss (from biggest to smallest loss) and long-term capital loss (from biggest to smallest).
How M1 Finance Investing Works
M1 Finance Individual and Joint Brokerage Accounts
M1 Finance is a hybrid investment app that combines self-directed trading and automated management. The app uses pie-based models that let you choose which stocks, ETFs, or portfolios you want to invest in and what percentage of your money you’d like to allocate toward each investment.
You can also invest in M1’s Model Portfolios, which are themed investment portfolios of stocks and ETFs aligned to different goals, such as socially responsible investing or retirement.
On the self-directed side, the M1 app lets you buy or sell individual securities or slices of your pie portfolio. M1 Finance offers fractional shares, auto-invest settings, dollar-cost averaging, portfolio rebalancing, and tax-minimization features. Margin trading is available for account balances over $2,000 at a competitive 7.25% rate.
M1 Finance Retirement Accounts
M1 Finance offers the following automated retirement account options:
Each retirement account allows you to pick your own stocks and ETFs, select professional portfolios, purchase fractional shares, and automatically reinvest dividends.
M1 Finance Custodial Accounts
M1 Finance offers UTMA/UGMA custodial account options for parents or guardians to invest on behalf of their children. Once your child or dependent reaches the age of majority in their state (usually 18 or 21), M1 Finance will restrict all trading on the account.
The custodial account beneficiary has two options once they reach the age of majority: Withdraw the funds or transfer them to another taxable investment account.
M1 Finance Crypto Account
The M1 Crypto account allows you to invest in commission-free cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Litecoin. You can currently create your own customized “pies” (or portfolios) and set target percentages for each pie. Automated trading is also available for cryptocurrencies.
You can also invest in the following crypto-related ETFs and trusts:
- ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BITO)
- Grayscale Ethereum Classic Trust ETF (ETCG)
- Grayscale Ethereum Trust (ETHE)
- Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC)
- Grayscale Litecoin Trust ETF (LTCN)
- Grayscale Digital Large Cap Fund LLC (GDLC)
You’ll also have access to M1 Finance’s large selection of OTC securities like Adidas (ADDYY), Nintendo Co., Ltd. (NTDOY), and Tesco PLC.
M1 Finance offers a custodial wallet powered by Bakkt.
M1 Finance Trust Accounts
If you’re considering setting up a trust account, you’ll need at least $5,000 to get started. M1 Finance supports both revocable and irrevocable trusts. You’ll need an existing M1 Finance account before you can set one up. Once signed up, you can add stocks, ETFs, real estate, cash, businesses, and more to your account.
M1 Finance encourages clients to consult an estate planning or family attorney before opening a trust.
M1 Finance Fees
M1 Finance requires a $100 minimum to open a standard individual or joint brokerage or crypto account. IRAs require a $500 account minimum, and trust accounts require a $5,000 minimum.
There’s a $3 monthly fee for accounts under $10,000. If your account is $50 or less and there has been no trading or deposit activity over 90 days, you may be subject to a $50 inactivity fee.
M1 Finance Trustworthiness
The Better Business Bureau has given M1 Finance an F rating. The BBB cites the number of complaints filed against the business as the reason for its rating.
The bureau primarily rates companies on customer interaction, complaint history, type of business, time in business, advertising issues, and licensing or government actions. The BBB also states that its ratings don’t predict whether a company will be reliable or perform well.
March 18, 2024, FINRA fined M1 Finance $850,000 for misleading and exaggerated claims made by influencers on the firm’s behalf. Approximately 1,700 influencers were working on the company’s behalf and promoting misleading information that violated multiple FINRA rules. M1 Finance failed to review influencers’ content and implement a reasonable system for supervising claims.
M1 Finance vs. Other Investment Apps
M1 Finance vs. Betterment
M1 Finance and Betterment Investing are both suitable choices for passive investors who want to utilize automated portfolio management. But fees, features, and account options differ for each platform.
If you’re solely interested in automated investing but don’t want to worry about minimum requirements to set up an account, Betterment is likely the better option. M1 Finance is preferred for investors who want access to both self-directed and automated investing features.
A downside to M1 Finance is that you’ll need a minimum of $500 to open an IRA. You can access automated IRAs without any minimums with Betterment.
M1 Finance vs. Wealthfront
Wealthfront InvestingM1 Finance and have many commonalities. Both offer ETFs and crypto exposure.
M1 Finance is better for active traders who want to trade stocks, ETFs, and cryptocurrencies. Wealthfront only offers crypto trusts, which give investors a more indirect exposure to the crypto market. You can only allocate up to 10% of your portfolio to crypto trusts with Wealthfront. But unlike M1 Finance, Wealthfront offers 529 plans.
Methodology: How We Reviewed M1 Finance
We examined M1 Finance investing using Business Insider’s rating methodology for investing platforms to compare and examine different brokerage account options, fees, security, and overall customer experience when reviewing investing platforms. Platforms are given a rating between 1 to 5.
Business Insider’s Overall M1 Finance Rating
M1 Finance Investing FAQs
M1 Finance is a comprehensive money-managing and investment app combining automated portfolio management with the flexibility of self-directed trading. You can access banking, investing, and loan services under one roof with M1 Finance. The platform also stands out with its unique “pie” investment model so investors can more easily invest in a larger selection of assets called “slices.”
M1 Finance is a commission-free trading platform offering a range of stocks, ETFs, fractional shares, and cryptocurrencies. No account management fees make it an appealing platform for fee-conscious investors. However, there is a $3 monthly fee to access premium features like extended trading hours, but the fee is waived for accounts of $10,000 or more.
M1 Finance is suitable for beginner investors who want the convenience of automated portfolio management with the flexibility to hand-pick the assets in their portfolio. The platform also offers pre-built Model portfolios aligned with various investment goals and risk tolerances. M1 Finance is also fairly low-cost, offering thousands of fractional shares called “slices” and commission-free stocks, ETFs, and cryptocurrencies.
Advanced investors can benefit from M1 Finance’s customizing capabilities integrated with automated portfolio management. Sophisticated traders can utilize the platform’s robust stock and ETF selection, dividend reinvesting features, and tax minimization strategies. However, M1 Finance doesn’t offer advanced charting tools or market data.
Beyond Investing, M1 Finance offers banking and borrowing services. You can open an M1 Spend checking account for cashback, integrated interest-earning capabilities, or a high-yield individual or joint savings account. M1 Borrow is the platform’s loan service, offering margin and personal loans at competitive rates.
