Rahul Bhatia is an SAP S/4HANA Cloud Solution Architect.
As different companies are adopting new technologies nowadays worldwide, it has become significant for different organizations to choose the most appropriate ERP solution that will help optimize finances and increase the enterprise’s sustainability and adaptability. SAP S/4HANA has two major Cloud delivery solution options: Public Cloud and Private Cloud. All these options come with their strengths and challenges, especially concerning financial activities, legal requirements and growth perspectives. Hence, deciding to go for SAP S/4HANA Public Cloud or SAP S/4HANA Private Cloud involves comparing costs, flexibility, compliance and security walls and business continuity plans, amongst others. This article aims to explain the disparity between SAP S/4HANA Public and Private Cloud, making it easier for the heads of finance to choose the most appropriate option to work with.
Understanding SAP S/4HANA Public and Private Cloud
There are different Cloud-based services in the SAP S/4HANA family that can definitely fulfill the exclusive requirements of different ranges and types of businesses.
SAP S/4HANA Public Cloud: A globally available multiple-company solution based on the software-as-a-service delivery model owned and operated by SAP, it is facilitated by its unique features of frequent updates, lower TCO and integration of best practices into its system.
SAP S/4HANA Private Cloud: This exclusive approach has more freedom, innovation and enhanced mobility than the standard one, which is typically implemented in RISE with SAP. This model makes available to business dedicated assets and enhances its possibilities to adapt processes in finance.
Key Considerations For Finance Teams
1. Cost And Total Cost Of Ownership (TCO)
From my experience as an SAP S/4HANA Cloud Solution Architect, the choice between Public and Private Cloud is often driven by cost considerations and Total Cost of Ownership (TCO).
• Public Cloud operates on a subscription-based pricing model, making it an attractive option for organizations that want to avoid heavy upfront investments in infrastructure. It offers a cost-effective, pay-as-you-go approach, reducing capital expenditure (capex) while shifting costs to operational expenses (opex). Additionally, because it runs on a shared infrastructure managed by SAP, businesses can benefit from automatic updates, security patches and system availability—freeing up IT resources from routine maintenance.
• Private Cloud, on the other hand, involves a higher initial investment due to dedicated resources and greater control over the system environment. While it offers more customization and security, it also demands higher operational costs for infrastructure maintenance, upgrades and IT management. Despite the higher TCO, organizations in highly regulated industries or those with complex financial structures often opt for Private Cloud to align with their unique business processes and compliance needs.
From my experience working with clients, this decision always comes down to balancing cost with flexibility and control. Organizations must evaluate whether they prioritize lower costs and managed services (Public Cloud) or greater customization and control at a premium (Private Cloud). Ultimately, the right choice depends on business needs, IT strategy and long-term scalability goals.
2. Scalability And Flexibility
• Public Cloud: It provides fast elasticity with canned configurations that the provider has deemed the best practices for the specific Cloud offering. The use of resources means that organizations can easily manage their growth because scaling up demand does not mean that they have to worry about where they will get the space to put the resources.
• Private Cloud: It offers the most effective flexibility regarding resource and service arrangements to suit individual business needs. Furthermore, it can be done as follows: If an organization finds its financial structures changing, then its ERP systems must also be changed.
3. Compliance And Security
• Public Cloud: Designed according to SAP’s global security policies and procedures and has inbuilt features of GDPR, its unique features are worth noting. Nonetheless, customers have raised significant concerns about data residency and security policies.
• Private Cloud: It provides improved security and regulations regarding data. It gives the choice of how the data stored in the Cloud can be handled from the compliance and regulatory point of view.
4. Innovation And System Updates
• Public Cloud: Comes with updates, meaning that the business gets to tap into the newest developments in SAP S/4HANA. It reduces expenses and keeps organizations in a position to have advanced financial instruments.
• Private Cloud: Allows for controlled updates to occur, thereby enabling business organizations to plan for updates and features in advance and also have a chance to carry out some tests on the impact of the updates. It is beneficial for companies with complicated financial processes.
5. Customization And Integration
• Public Cloud: It has limited flexibility, and so does it help in setting a standard because of an apparently good practice of financial processes.
• Private Cloud: It allows for the adaptations to be made, enabling the firms to have unique financial reporting solutions, procedures and interfaces to different programs.
6. Performance And Business Continuity
• Public Cloud: It offers very high availability of the infrastructure managed by SAP, although there could be fewer options for tweaking the performance.
• Private Cloud: It is considered more appropriate for controlling system performance and is perfect for many things, for instance, the processing of several transactions and complex mathematical calculations in the financial sector, to name a few.
From my experience as an SAP S/4HANA Solution Architect, selecting between Public and Private Cloud depends on balancing cost, flexibility and control. Public Cloud is ideal for businesses seeking a cost-effective, standardized solution with automatic updates and minimal IT maintenance. However, it works best for companies that can adapt to SAP’s best practices with limited customization.
For industries like finance, healthcare and manufacturing, where compliance, security and deep customization are critical, Private Cloud is often the preferred choice. While it requires higher investment and IT expertise, it offers greater control and flexibility over upgrades and integrations.
Lately, I’ve seen many companies embracing hybrid models, leveraging SAP BTP to integrate Public Cloud efficiency with Private Cloud flexibility, ensuring a scalable and future-proof ERP strategy.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?
